Sunday Musings w/ Shore Branding – 2-15-15

Sunday Musings w/ Shore Branding - The Super Bowl Edition! (Photo credit: MixedNutsAndLove.deviantart.com)

Sunday Musings w/ Shore Branding – A look into NFL branding
(Photo credit: MixedNutsAndLove.deviantart.com)

This weekend’s #SundayMusings will focus on the NFL and NFL branding.  While the league has clearly become America’s favorite sport with millions watching every weekend, it certainly doesn’t have its warts.  The league can’t seem to stay out of the news in a negative way as well.  Check ESPN’s NFL page at any point and you are likely to see at least one headline of a legal issue.

The 2014 season started off with the Ray Rice domestic abuse incident and Adrian Peterson’s child abuse case, then finished with “DeflateGate”.  Commissioner Roger Goodell stumbled and bumbled all the way through both, leading to more terrible PR for the league.

Within hours of the season ending in Super Bowl XLIX, the NFL found itself with more controversy.  Cleveland Browns QB Johnny Manziel checked himself into rehab and his star WR was busted once again and suspended for all of the 2015 NFL season.  None of this is good news but the NFL will survive.

Typically in #SundayMusings we look for stories within the past week or two to discuss.  However, we’re going a little further back this week and looking at various articles that have been written about the NFL’s branding and how/where the league stands to benefit.

#1 – “The NFL Brand – Discuss” – via Forbes.com

Premise: With several of the stories listed above hot in the news, the author conducts a ‘roundtable’ discussion on the NFL brand with several strong minds in the marketing and advertising space.

Thoughts: Excellent reference to the NFL as “The Teflon Brand” as no matter what the issue has been, the NFL has moved past it and gotten stronger in the ratings.  There are a lot of good ideas and thoughts in this piece and is worth the read, particularly behind the last question/thought, “can a brand be too strong, too powerful?” [Read more…]

Super Bowl Ad Review 2015

 

It is that time again!  Last weekend’s Super Bowl XLIX managed to break the preceding year’s viewership record, drawing 114.5 million viewers vs. last year’s 112.2 million.  This year’s Super Bowl was one for the ages, even if my favorite team lost in heartbreaking fashion.  That also meant that more people were still glued to their TV as the game wore on and the brands that spent money for advertising late in the game got what they paid for – attention.

As we have done in the past (2014 & 2013), here is my Super Bowl ad review from a panel of one.  One important caveat for this year’s countdown – there are two countdowns here.  Welcoming a newborn to the family in mid 2014 leads to a complete bias for the sappy ‘Dad’ commercials.  So I’m ranking those separately.  They would be at or near the top of the regular countdown.  Aside from the Seahawks pulling on heart strings, the ads in the “second countdown” below also led to me needing to call my own timeouts.  Good grief.

The overall countdown: [Read more…]

Sunday Musings w/ Shore Branding – 2-1-15

Sunday Musings w/ Shore Branding - The Super Bowl Edition! (Photo credit: MixedNutsAndLove.deviantart.com)

Sunday Musings w/ Shore Branding – The Super Bowl Edition!
(Photo credit: MixedNutsAndLove.deviantart.com)

Welcome to a Super Bowl edition of #SundayMusings!  With some skin in the game for the second year in a row, the nerves are a little shot, as the Seattle Seahawks look to become the first team in a decade to win two Super Bowls in a row.  Ironically, the last team to do so is their opponent later today, the New England Patriots.

Let’s take a look at the top Super Bowl-related stories that have caught my attention over the past few weeks in branding and advertising.  Next weekend will be our third annual Super Bowl ad review, an article I have thoroughly enjoyed writing the first two times around!  With that in mind, I’m trying to avoid picking articles that have highlighted some of the early newsmaking ads.

#1 – “Only 46% of Super Bowl Advertisers Will Score Consumer Engagement” – via AdWeek.com

Premise: A $4.5 million dollar ad spend will get you less than 50% of your audience’s engagement, according to Brand Keys 13th Annual Super Bowl Ad Engagement survey.  Interviewing 2,705 people that intend to watch the Super Bowl the projected big winners include the likes of Super Bowl regulars like Doritos, GoDaddy, and others such as Skittles.  Two of the bigger brands to annually invest in Super Bowl ads – McDonald’s and Budweiser – don’t score well on building engagement.

Thoughts: Interesting “copy testing” like research ahead of the Super Bowl.  You have to wonder how deflating it is to spend all of this money and hear news like this about a negatively received ad before it even airs later today.  Here’s the link to the PDF directly from Brand Keys and the article from AdWeek includes a matrix that measures Engagement and Entertainment across the brand’s ads. [Read more…]